Jurisprudencia y Ciencias Sociales

URI permanente para esta comunidadhttp://repositorio.uta.edu.ec/handle/123456789/892

Examinar

Resultados de la búsqueda

Mostrando 1 - 2 de 2
  • Item type:Ítem,
    La tauromaquia frente al nuevo paradigma de los animales como sujetos de derechos en Ambato - Ecuador
    (Universidad Técnica de Ambato, Facultad de Jurisprudencia y Ciencias Sociales, Carrera de Derecho, 2026-07-08)
    Moreta Guevara, Angel Lizandro
    ;
    Vargas Salazar, Gavino
    Bullfighting has been, for decades, one of the most representative cultural expressions of several Ecuadorian localities. However, in recent years its continued practice has been questioned due to the growing recognition of animals as sentient beings and the evolution of legal mechanisms designed for their protection. This situation has generated a debate that transcends the cultural sphere and reaches the constitutional level, especially when deeply rooted traditions are confronted with new conceptions of animal welfare and rights. This study focuses on the reality of the Ambato canton, where bullfighting events continue to be part of certain festivities. Based on this, the study analyzes how Ecuadorian law, constitutional jurisprudence, and specialized legal scholarship address the relationship between bullfighting and the recognition of animals as subjects of legal protection. The importance of this topic lies in the need to understand how to resolve the conflicts that arise between rights, principles, and values recognized within the national legal system. To achieve this objective, a qualitative approach was employed, supported by historical-legal, analytical-synthetic, and comparative law methods, in addition to a review of normative, bibliographic, and jurisprudential sources, complemented by interviews with legal professionals. This work is part of a research line related to Constitutional Law and the rights of nature. Among its main contributions are the identification of normative inconsistencies regarding the legal treatment of animals in bullfighting, as well as the proposal of criteria that allow for a more harmonious interpretation between animal protection and the cultural expressions recognized by Ecuadorian legislation.
  • Item type:Ítem,
    La tauromaquia: un caso de colision de derechos
    (Universidad Tècnica de Ambato, Facultad de Jurisprudencia y Ciencias Sociales, Carrera de Derecho, 2024-08)
    Espinosa Gutierrez, Kimberly Roxana
    ;
    Saca Balladares, Melinton Fernando
    This research work titled “BULLFIGHTING: A CASE OF COLLISION OF RIGHTS” focuses on determining the collision of rights present in this practice. It includes a historical investigation of bullfighting, analysis of international and national regulations, analysis of related court rulings and municipal ordinances, and the use of methodology to gather information, aiming to provide a broader understanding of the subject. It is important to highlight that the Ecuadorian state guarantees the fundamental rights enshrined in the Constitution, emphasizing the principle of equality. This research analyzed the fundamental rights that collide in the practice: the right to culture and the rights of nature. The research project was carried out through a qualitative approach; it is descriptive and exploratory in nature. The selected instrument was the interview, which was conducted with seven individuals knowledgeable in law and experienced in the field of bullfighting. Despite the evident collision of rights in the practice of bullfighting, a popular referendum was held in 2011 that involved the decision of the people with the question, "Do you agree that in the canton of your residence, shows that aim to kill the animal should be banned?" to democratically decide whether to prohibit or accept bullfighting involving the death of the bull. The results were favorable in some cities and not in others; the decision chosen by the people remains in effect to this day, without considering the violation of rights that this practice involves. Finally, bullfighting is an art protected by culture, which harms the life of an animal (the fighting bull). This research creates an obligation to conduct a balancing test to perform a proportional analysis of the fundamental rights involved in bullfighting